Linguistique de l’écrit

Revue internationale en libre accès

Collections | Livre | Chapitre

206446

Challenges to characterizing the notion of causation across disciplinary boundaries

comment on faye

Jan Baedke

pp. 191-201

Résumé

This paper comments on Jan Faye's metadisciplinary characterization of the notion of causation. I will argue that his understanding of a causal factor as a difference-maker can be specified by relating it to similarity considerations and analogical reasoning about causal dependencies. At the same time, however, his notion of a difference-maker does not capture what is understood as a cause in many biological and biophysical investigations of robustness of living systems (e.g. in systems biology). Finally, I will show that Faye ignores crucial differences between causal processes and causal mechanisms.

Détails de la publication

Publié dans:

Dieks Dennis, Hartmann Stephan, Uebel Thomas, Weber Marcel, Galavotti Maria Carla (2014) New directions in the philosophy of science. Dordrecht, Springer.

Pages: 191-201

DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-04382-1_13

Citation complète:

Baedke Jan, 2014, Challenges to characterizing the notion of causation across disciplinary boundaries: comment on faye. In D. Dieks, S. Hartmann, T. Uebel, M. Weber & M. Galavotti (eds.) New directions in the philosophy of science (191-201). Dordrecht, Springer.